Brevidy vs Cutback
Finished social captions in Premiere. Cutback meters a cleanup suite with graphic clips.
Last reviewed
The verdict
Brevidy is the clearer Cutback alternative when your job is social video that ships from Premiere: a transcript editor that edits like a document and auto-applies to one caption layer, ~95% accuracy cloud captions, 700+ one-click presets that land formatted correctly, team shared styles, plus active-speaker AutoCrop, AI clip picks, and stock media in one panel. Premiere Assistant by Cutback lands near Captioner’s yearly sticker on Basic ($13/mo) and undercuts on Lite ($8/mo), but buys a metered cleanup suite: own cloud ASR, native graphic-clip captions, multicam speaker switch, silence/filler/retakes. Choose Cutback for Lite sticker, multicam switching, text-based cleanup breadth, Selects multi-NLE prep, or Adobe Video Partner update cadence.
| Capability |  |  |
|---|---|---|
| Captions | ||
| Ease of use | Easiest Doc-style · one layer | More steps ~8 steps · sync breaks |
| Animated captions | Word-by-word engine | Native graphic clips |
| Style presets | 700+ Trending + defaults | Style library No published count |
| Transcript editor | Doc-style Intuitive · auto-applies | Solid editor Word-level · tidy tools |
| Restyle & reformat | Instant Lines, chars, breaks: whole set | Format + presets Tidy · re-apply style |
| AI highlights | Manual + AI suggest | Spoken-word style Karaoke / word highlight |
| Transcription | ||
| Accuracy & models | 95% 3 cloud models to choose | Own cloud ASR No published WER |
| Diarization, vocab, translate | 99+ languages | Translate yes 100+ ASR · ~29–30+ translate |
| Offline | No | Cloud · ~200 Mbps upload |
| Beyond captions | ||
| AutoCrop / reframe | Active-speaker reframing | Multicam switch Speaker→camera, not crop |
| Silence & cleanup | AI clip picks + silence cut | Silence · fillers · retakes |
| Stock media | In-panel library | Cutback Browser |
| Teams & pricing | ||
| Team presets & roles | Shared library + admin roles | Enterprise admin No org preset library |
| Caption minutes | 100 / mo Captioner; unlimited on Producer | Hour pools No rollover · 2-hr cap |
| Price | $14.99/mo Captioner: finished captions | $13/mo Basic yearly, Lite $8/mo |
| Free plan | 10-min sample + 7-day trial | 3 transcriptions / mo |
| Lifetime license | No | No |
Near-parity sticker. Better finished social.
Cutback Basic can match the monthly number and list more cleanup tools. Brevidy wins the minutes from rough captions to a look you publish.
Brevidy Captioner
$14.99/mo
Billed yearly
Billed yearly ($179.90/yr). $17.99 monthly. 100 captioning minutes for the path from transcript to finished captions (editor toolkit + one-click formatted presets + published accuracy). Need unlimited captions + AutoCrop/AutoCut workflow minutes? Producer is $29.99/mo yearly.
Try before you buy
Free 10-min sample + 7-day trial.
Basic
$13/mo
Billed yearly ($13/mo) or $15/mo monthly. Near Captioner’s yearly sticker for 20 transcription hours/mo (no rollover), multicam up to 3 cams, silence/translate meters, and animated captions: a cleanup suite card. Lite undercuts at $8/mo yearly (3 hr/mo). Pro is $30/mo yearly (30 hr/mo). Re-check https://cutback.video/premiere-assistant/pricing.
Try before you buy
Starter: 3 transcriptions/mo (≤30 min each).
From real editors
Linked praise for Brevidy’s ease. Cutback has almost no independent public review trail, so the friction below is quoted from their own help center.
On Brevidy
“My team and I have recently switched to using Brevidy. For one, it makes all the captions as one simple layer instead of generating multiple mogrts or PNG files in your timeline… it's the most convenient version that we have used yet.”
“It's the only one I've encountered so far where it's fairly effortless to move the words/sentences to/from different spots.”
“Brevidy works extremely well… the best part about it by far IMO is its accuracy transcribing… Premiere usually gives me ~80% accuracy… Brevidy's formatting tools are really easy to learn and use. Sometimes I'll use it just to create an SRT… because it's just so much better than Premiere.”
On Cutback
“Captions are not synced in real time. If you edit the timeline after transcribing, the captions may no longer match your speech.”
“Split your video into segments under 30 minutes… remove effects, un-nest multicam sequences, delete unused tracks and free up memory.”
No attributable Reddit, Trustpilot, or Adobe-forum complaints turned up for Cutback. The two quotes above are Cutback documenting its own limits.
Straight talk
When Cutback is the better fit
Need Lite at $8/mo yearly, Basic near Captioner at $13/mo yearly, multicam speaker→camera switching, the broadest text-based cleanup (silence, fillers, retakes, edit-to-script), Selects for Final Cut / Resolve prep, Adobe Video Partner status and update cadence, a free Starter tier with 3 recurring transcriptions a month, or their own cloud ASR (they are not reselling Adobe’s)? Premiere Assistant by Cutback wins those. If captions are the product (published accuracy, 700+ presets that land right, a transcript editor on one living layer, team brand styles, and active-speaker AutoCrop in Premiere), Brevidy is the better buy at near-parity Basic sticker.
What Cutback gets wrong
Brevidy “uses MOGRT… 20–40 times slower than graphic captions”
Misleading implication. Brevidy places one MOGRT clip that holds the entire caption set on a single track (extended with an additional segment only when a sequence outruns one clip) and rewrites that clip’s encoded fields in place on edit, not one .mogrt per caption line like Captioneer or SubMachine. Cutback’s speed claim is their in-house experiment comparing graphic clips to a per-line MOGRT stack; it does not describe Brevidy’s one-layer apply path. Compare finished presets and editor finish, not an invented render race.
“Clunky transcription editing UI” / “shortcuts are not supported”
Outdated / opinion. Brevidy ships a transcript editor: edit like a document, split/merge lines and blocks, search/replace, manual + AI highlights, whole-set reformatting. Edits auto-apply to one caption layer. Shortcuts and the living-set editor are first-class.
Caption-only $14.99/mo; full $29.99/mo (presented as flat monthly)
Those figures are yearly-billed monthly equivalents. Captioner is $14.99/mo when billed yearly ($179.90/yr), or $17.99/mo billed monthly. Producer is $29.99/mo yearly ($359.90/yr), or $35.99/mo monthly: unlimited captions plus AutoCrop/AutoCut workflow minutes, not a flat “$29.99 captions” SKU.
FAQ
Yes, for social video that ships from Premiere. Brevidy wins on an intuitive transcript editor, ~95% accuracy captions, 700+ one-click formatted presets, team shared styles, active-speaker AutoCrop, AI clips, and stock media. Choose Premiere Assistant by Cutback instead for Lite at $8/mo yearly, multicam speaker switching, broader silence/filler/retakes cleanup, Selects multi-NLE prep, Adobe Video Partner updates, or a free Starter with 3 transcriptions a month.
Ease and finish. Brevidy’s transcript editor edits like a document and auto-applies to one caption layer, with ~95% accuracy (~5% WER), selectable models, diarization, custom vocabulary, 99+ languages, AI emphasis highlights, team shared presets, and whole-set reformatting. Cutback ships a real caption product (own cloud ASR, solid word-level editor, native graphic-clip animated captions, style library) but publishes no WER, no preset count, and documents an ~8-step path where timeline edits after transcribe break sync.
Lite wins the sticker at $8/mo yearly. Basic ($13/mo yearly) is near Captioner ($14.99/mo yearly). Cutback can win the tool-count card; Brevidy wins cost-per-finished social caption when you count fix-and-restyle time. Pro ($30/mo yearly) sits near Producer ($29.99/mo yearly) but meters 30 transcription hours with no rollover; Producer bundles unlimited captions with AutoCrop/AutoCut workflow minutes. Free Starter (3 jobs/mo) undercuts Brevidy’s one-sample Free plan for recurring tries.
No. Cutback multicam switches cameras when a speaker talks. Useful for multi-angle shoots, not the same as Brevidy AutoCrop, which reframes a single clip around the active speaker with editable Premiere transform keyframes.
No. Premiere Assistant uses Cutback’s own cloud ASR, not Premiere Speech-to-Text. They publish no WER figure; Brevidy markets ~95% accuracy (~5% WER) with three selectable cloud modes. Both require the network.
No. Cloud ASR with a recommended ~200 Mbps upload. Brevidy is also cloud for transcription. Need true offline Whisper-style captions? See /alternatives/brevidy-vs-captioneer.
Cutback wins toolkit breadth: silence, fillers, retakes, edit-to-script, shortform, text-based trim (silence uses metered except unlimited on Pro). Brevidy includes silence removal and AI clip extraction inside AutoCut on Producer. If text-based cleanup is the only job, Cutback; if captions-plus-cleanup in one social finish is the job, Brevidy.
Enterprise admin billing and Pro multi-device, yes. An org-scoped shared brand preset library like Brevidy Team plans is not documented. Custom caption templates stay tied to the account email.
Selects is a separate prep SKU that exports to Premiere, Final Cut, and Resolve: a real multi-NLE win Brevidy does not match. It is not the Premiere Assistant caption product. Compare Selects on its own pricing page if prep/handoff is the job; compare Premiere Assistant vs Brevidy for in-Premiere captions.
Yes. Captions Cutback already placed are ordinary Premiere timeline objects (caption track or native graphic clips in their nested workflow) and stay put. New captions use Brevidy’s presets and editor. Export an SRT from Cutback if you need a text handoff.