Brevidy vs FireCut
Social captions on one layer, not capped ASR into PNG tracks.
Last reviewed
The verdict
Brevidy is the clearer FireCut alternative when your job is social captions in Premiere: a transcript editor that edits like a document and rewrites one caption layer in place, ~95% accuracy cloud ASR, 700+ one-click presets that land formatted correctly, team shared styles, plus active-speaker AutoCrop, AI clip picks, and stock media. FireCut Premiere Pro is $20/mo yearly for a wider cleanup suite, but styled captions land as PNG image clips on a new track (edits re-add to another new track per their docs), transcription is metered (25h/mo Pro, 100h Max), and non-English ASR is self-described as experimental at 70-80%. Choose FireCut for suite breadth, DaVinci Resolve (including Linux), silence-only Starter, podcast multi-track, zooms, chapters, Storyblocks B-roll, or a requestable lifetime license.
| Capability |  |  |
|---|---|---|
| Captions | ||
| Ease of use | Easiest Transcript editor · one layer | More steps ~5-step path · re-add on edit |
| Animated captions | Word-by-word engine | Styled PNG clips |
| Caption output | One layer Single MOGRT · edit in place | PNG track New track every edit |
| Style presets | 700+ Trending + defaults | Templates No Premiere built-in count |
| Transcript editor | Doc-style Intuitive · auto-applies | In-panel editor Words · then re-add PNGs |
| Restyle & reformat | Instant Lines, chars, breaks: whole set | Style · re-add New PNG track |
| AI highlights | Manual + AI suggest | Spoken-word style No AI emphasis tool |
| Transcription | ||
| Accuracy & models | 95% 3 cloud models to choose | Unpublished % Own cloud ASR · no WER |
| Languages | 99+ · Transcribe + translate | 50+ claimed Non-EN experimental 70–80% |
| Offline | No | Cloud AI · license online |
| Beyond captions | ||
| AutoCrop / reframe | Active-speaker reframing | Auto Reframe Premiere’s tool · not speaker |
| Silence & cleanup | AI clip picks + silence cut | Yes, broader · Silence, fillers, more |
| Stock media / B-roll | In-panel library | Storyblocks included (FAQ) |
| DaVinci Resolve | Premiere Pro only | Win / Mac / Linux |
| Teams & pricing | ||
| Team presets & roles | Shared library + admin roles | Seats + share Team presets · not full brand lib |
| Caption / transcription pool | 100 / mo Captioner; unlimited on Producer | 25h / mo Pro; 100h on Max |
| Price | $14.99/mo Captioner: finished captions | $20/mo Premiere Pro yearly: captions |
| Free plan | 10-min sample + 7-day trial | Trial + Resolve Free 7-day · silence Free on Resolve |
| Lifetime license | No | Request-only No public price |
Cheaper caption plan. One layer, not PNGs.
FireCut Pro can list more cleanup tools. Brevidy wins the minutes from rough captions to a look you publish, without a new PNG track on every edit.
Brevidy Captioner
$14.99/mo
Billed yearly
Billed yearly ($179.90/yr). $17.99 monthly. 100 captioning minutes, priced for the path from transcript to finished captions (editor toolkit + one-click formatted presets + published accuracy). Need unlimited captions + AutoCrop/AutoCut workflow minutes? Producer is $29.99/mo yearly.
Try before you buy
Free 10-min sample + 7-day trial.
FireCut Premiere Pro
$20/mo
Billed yearly at $20/mo ($34/mo monthly). Cheapest FireCut Premiere plan that includes captions. Starter ($10/mo yearly) is silence-cutting only with no captions. Pro includes 25 hours transcription/month for the full AI suite (zooms, chapters, podcast, B-roll, etc.). Max is $34/mo yearly with 100h. Re-check https://firecut.ai/pricing/premiere-pro/.
Try before you buy
7-day trial · Resolve Free silence tier.
From real editors
Linked praise for Brevidy’s ease. FireCut has little independent review trail, so the limits below are quoted from FireCut’s own documentation.
On Brevidy
“My team and I have recently switched to using Brevidy. For one, it makes all the captions as one simple layer instead of generating multiple mogrts or PNG files in your timeline… it's the most convenient version that we have used yet.”
“Best solution I've found is a tool called Brevidy. It's a subscription, which absolutely sucks. I hate paying monthly for tools. But I learned how to do captions myself, word by word, and a one minute video took forever to give animated captions to.”
“My team of 10 and all our subcontractors use Brevidy.”
On FireCut
“Other languages are experimental and are expected to be 70-80% correct in most cases.”
“Styled captions are added as PNG images on a new video track… to edit them you select the caption clips and add them again to a new track.”
FireCut’s public reviews are overwhelmingly positive on the wider suite, especially podcast and silence tools. We couldn’t verify attributable complaint threads, so the quotes above are FireCut describing its own caption behaviour.
Straight talk
When FireCut is the better fit
Need an enormous AI edit suite (silence, fillers, repetition, profanity, zooms, chapters, podcast multi-track, highlights/shorts, B-roll, voiceover, workflows) plus DaVinci Resolve (including Linux), a free Resolve silence tier, Premiere Starter at $10/mo yearly for silence-only cutting, Storyblocks B-roll included per their FAQ, a 7-day trial, or a requestable lifetime license? FireCut wins those. If captions are the product (published ~95% accuracy, 700+ presets that land right, a transcript editor on one layer instead of PNG re-adds, team brand styles, and active-speaker AutoCrop in Premiere), Brevidy is the better buy, and Captioner undercuts FireCut Premiere Pro’s yearly sticker.
What FireCut gets wrong
Brevidy costs $30/mo
Misleading third-party claim (Captioneer comparison cluster). Captioner is $14.99/mo yearly ($17.99 monthly). Producer is $29.99/mo yearly for unlimited captions plus AutoCrop/AutoCut workflow minutes, not a flat “$30 captions” SKU. FireCut itself does not publish this about Brevidy.
Brevidy has a 6.6-hour transcription limit
False as a transcription ceiling (same Captioneer SERP cluster). ~6.6 hours ≈ Producer’s 400 monthly video-workflow minutes for AutoCut/AutoCrop, not captioning. Producer and Team Pro captioning is unlimited; Captioner is 100 caption minutes/mo.
Brevidy Captioner / Producer prices are flat monthly rates at the yearly sticker
Cutback’s listicle has shown Captioner $14.99 and Producer ~$29.99 without clear yearly vs monthly framing. Those are yearly monthly-equivalents ($179.90/yr and $359.90/yr). Monthly billing is $17.99 and $35.99.
FAQ
Yes, for social captions in Premiere. Brevidy wins on a transcript editor that rewrites one caption layer in place, ~95% accuracy, 700+ one-click formatted presets, team shared styles, active-speaker AutoCrop, AI clips, and stock media. Choose FireCut instead for suite breadth (silence → podcast → zooms → chapters → shorts), DaVinci Resolve including Linux, silence-only Starter pricing, Storyblocks B-roll, or a requestable lifetime license.
Output mechanism and finish loop. FireCut’s own docs say styled captions are PNG images on a new video track, and edits re-add to another new track, plus an occasional diagonal-stripes reopen failure needing Interpret Footage. Brevidy places one MOGRT holding the whole set and edits rewrite it in place, with ~95% accuracy (~5% WER), selectable models, diarization, custom vocabulary, 99+ languages, and 700+ presets. FireCut ships captions and an in-panel transcript editor. The timeline model and usage caps are the gap.
On caption-capable Premiere plans, Captioner ($14.99/mo yearly) undercuts FireCut Premiere Pro ($20/mo yearly). FireCut Starter ($10/mo yearly) is cheaper but silence-only, with no captions. Max is $34/mo yearly with 100h transcription. Producer ($29.99/mo yearly) costs more because it bundles unlimited captions with AutoCrop/AutoCut workflow minutes. Compare cost-per-finished caption (fix + restyle time + 25h Pro pool), not tool count.
Yes for styled captions. FireCut FAQ: PNG image clips on a new video track; editing means adding them again to a new track. They also offer a text-only Premiere captions track and SRT/VTT export. Brevidy uses one MOGRT layer for the whole set and edits in place, not a PNG stack.
Yes on Premiere. Pro is 25 hours transcription per month; Max is 100h. Resolve SKUs use different caps (Captions 8h, Pro 10h, Max 50h/week). Brevidy Captioner is 100 caption minutes/mo; Producer captioning is unlimited (video-workflow minutes for AutoCut/AutoCrop are separate).
FireCut publishes no WER. Their add-captions docs call non-English languages experimental and “expected to be 70–80% correct in most cases,” with English fully supported. Brevidy markets ~95% accuracy (~5% WER) with three selectable cloud modes. Judge both on a trial with your accent and language.
No. Not the same feature. FireCut highlights can use Premiere’s Auto Reframe or beta face-detection viewboxes. Brevidy AutoCrop reframes around the active speaker with editable Premiere transform keyframes. Do not treat Auto Reframe as AutoCrop.
Yes. Resolve Free + Studio on Windows, Mac, and Linux, with a separate pricing ladder including a free silence tier. Brevidy is Premiere Pro only. Resolve editors should start with FireCut (or AutoCut).
FireCut if silence (and fillers/repetition/profanity) is the job. Starter is silence-only from $10/mo yearly, and Resolve Free includes unlimited silence tools. Brevidy includes silence removal inside AutoCut on Producer alongside AI clip extraction. Pure silence cleanup favors FireCut’s suite.
PNG caption clips already on the timeline stay as ordinary Premiere media (bring the PNG files if you move the project; Cutback notes offline media when PNGs are missing). New captions use Brevidy’s one-layer presets and editor. Export SRT/VTT from FireCut if you need a text handoff.